I’ve long held Bounty Hunter Wines in high regard. They are a Napa based wine store who excel in supplying high end Californian wines. They produce an excellent catalog, and they evoke a mystique about their craft. I feel like an explorer just by reading it.
When I suddenly found myself driving past their store/winebar on Friday night (it had slipped my mind that they were based in Napa) I felt like I’d found home. The place was fantastic - a casual, saloon style bar; I could smell the barbecue from outside the door. Tens of wines by the glass, and best of all tasting flights.
Now, before i go any further, let me say: I still do hold the company in high regard, and most of the wines I tried were great and the food was excellent. However…
The staff at Bounty Hunter served me two corked wines in a row. Bad enough, but then the waiter refused to believe that they were in fact corked. His disdainful response was that I was in fact mistaking Oak for the wet cardboard smell I complained about! (coincidentally both were bottled under Bounty Hunter’s own label (Pursuit)).
I work in the wine industry and have a nose for corked wines. I don’t just mean off-smelling barnyard style wines, or wines contaminated with any of the tens of other chemicals that can make a wine pong, but a wine that’s tainted with TCA. Trust me, after tasting thousands of wines a year, if it smells of wet cardboard and over the space of an hour turns undrinkable I know it’s corked.
I don’t want this to sully any potential relationship with Bounty Hunter, and we’d love to feature their wines at Snooth, and I most certainly would recommend to anyone that they stop in there on a visit to Napa.
The message I want to convey here, however, is that I see the kind of pretension that the waiter showed me, that night, in the wine industry far too often and it needs to change. The typical wine drinker might detect that the wine was off, and be too timid to say anything, or worse, be shot down if they dared.
P.S. Why the title? Somewhere between 5 and 15% of wines are corked. Lets take the average: 10%. That makes the chance of getting two wines in a row that are corked 1 in 100.
If you are looking for advice on how to save a corked wine, refer to my earlier post on saving a wine that’s corked.